By Jim Wright
The […] novel sucked. Even when I liked Heinlein I saw right through that Rah Rah Military is Awesome bullshit.
– Facebook Comment
I met a man who despised me.
He called me fascist, murderer, and a dumb blunt tool.
I didn’t take it personally – though a younger me might have.
I didn’t meet him in the flesh, like most of my social interactions these days I encountered him online. He surfaced on a well known author’s Facebook page during a conversation regarding a certain well known classic science fiction novel.
The novel was, of course, Robert A. Heinlein’s Starship Troopers.
But really it doesn’t matter which author or what novel or exactly where the conversation took place. The conversation and the novel which inspired it aren’t relevant to this essay, other than as a starting point. Suffice it to say the novel and the reputation of its author is such that fully six decades after it was written it still has the unerring ability to generate violent conflict and powerful emotions. Mention it in any conversation about government and/or military service and the sparks will fly.
It’s one of those books you either love or hate.
Very few who are familiar with the work find middle ground between those poles – including those who haven’t actually read it and are familiar with the writer and the novel only by second-hand heresy (yes, heresy, the book is nearly an article of faith to many) and a terrible Hollywood adaption.
It’s one of those stories where your opinion depends very much on your age and experience, and as such your opinion with regards to the story tends to change and temper over time.
To me, well, that’s what makes it a truly great work.
Love it, hate it, it is a coming of age story and it endures as …read more
Via:: Stone Kettle Station